The Post-AEP Checklist Every Insurance Agency Needs
What to verify, file, and flag in the two weeks after AEP closes — before Medicare Advantage OEP and the ACA's January 15 deadline catch your agency off guard.
The post-AEP checklist for insurance agencies starts the morning after December 7: confirm every January 1 enrollment actually reached the carrier, lock down your Scope of Appointment and call-recording files before anyone archives them, clean up the duplicate records the rush created, and flag Medicare Advantage clients who still have one more chance to change their mind. Do that work in the first two weeks, not in March when the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period is already half over. Why the Two Weeks After AEP Matter The Annual Enrollment Period runs October 15 through December 7, and any plan change made during it takes effect January 1 — but only if the plan received the request by the December 7 deadline. Medicare.gov is explicit that the request has to reach the plan, not just get submitted on the agent's end . That gap — submitted versus received and confirmed — is where agencies lose enrollments every year, and it's invisible until a client calls in February asking why their new plan never started. At the same time, two more enrollment windows are already open or about to open. The Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period runs January 1 through March 31 and lets anyone already in a Medicare Advantage plan make one additional switch — to a different MA plan, or back to Original Medicare. And the ACA Marketplace's own Open Enrollment Period doesn't close until January 15, with a December 15 cutoff for January 1 coverage and the final deadline pushing a February 1 start. HealthCare.gov lays out both cutoffs on its dates-and-deadlines page . An agency that treats December 7 as the finish line is walking into both of those windows unprepared. The Post-AEP Close-Out Checklist Work through this in order. Each item is something you can check off in a CRM, not a vague goal. Reconcile submitted vs. confirmed enrollments. Pull every policy record your team touched between October 15 and December 7 and separate "submitted" from "carrier-confirmed." Anything still showing as submitted a week after AEP closed needs a phone call to the carrier, not an assumption that it went through. Re-run your duplicate check. AEP call volume creates duplicate contacts and duplicate household members faster than any other time of year — a client calls three different agents on three different days and ends up as three records. Our CRM data hygiene checklist covers the dedupe pass; run it again now, not just before the next AEP. Confirm Scope of Appointment and consent records are filed, not just signed. A signed SOA sitting in a rep's email or a paper folder isn't a filed SOA. Retention requirements and what counts as a complete record are covered in our SOA record-keeping guide — use this close-out week to confirm every AEP appointment's SOA actually made it into the client's record. Confirm call recordings are retained, not just captured. Recording a call and retaining it in a searchable, attributable way are two different systems. Our call recording requirements guide goes through what has to be kept; close-out week is when you verify nothing from AEP's highest call volume got dropped. Flag every Medicare Advantage client for the OEP window. January 1 through March 31, an MA enrollee gets exactly one more switch. Tag clients who are brand new to an MA plan, or who expressed hesitation during AEP, so your team knows who's worth a check-in call before March 31 closes the window for good. Separate your ACA book by deadline, not by "done." Marketplace clients who enrolled or changed plans by December 15 are locked in for January 1. Anyone who hasn't acted yet has until January 15 for a February 1 start. Those are two different follow-up lists, not one. Update coverage-type and policy-status fields for clients who made no change. "No change" still needs to be recorded as a reviewed status, not left blank — a blank field next AEP looks identical to "we never contacted this client," and you'll waste time re-verifying work you already did. Pull a book growth and retention snapshot. Before memory of the season fades, capture where the book actually landed — net adds, net losses, and which lines moved. AgencyView's Book Growth & Retention report freezes each month's figures at close so this number doesn't quietly shift later; see our book growth and retention report guide . Calendar the next three closing dates. December 15 (ACA January 1 cutoff), January 15 (ACA OEP ends), and March 31 (MA OEP ends). Put all three on the agency calendar now, not as a note to "remember in January." Medicare AEP vs. Medicare Advantage OEP: What Changes Window Dates Who it applies to What's allowed Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) Oct 15 – Dec 7 Anyone with Medicare Join, switch, or drop any MA or Part D plan Medicare Advantage OEP Jan 1 – Mar 31 Only those already enrolled in an MA plan One switch to a different MA plan, or back to Original Medicare The practical difference for your pipeline: AEP leads are anyone with Medicare, but OEP leads are a strict subset — only people already sitting in an MA plan — and each of them only gets to use the window once. Medicare.gov's enrollment-periods page spells out that one-switch limit . The ACA Marketplace Isn't Finished on December 7 It's easy for a Medicare-focused agency to treat December 7 as the all-clear and for an ACA-focused one to relax too early. Marketplace Open Enrollment actually runs November 1 through January 15. HealthCare.gov's own guidance puts it plainly : enroll by December 15 for coverage starting January 1; enroll by January 15 and coverage starts February 1 instead. Any client who hasn't completed a plan selection by mid-December needs to know which of those two dates applies to them — and needs to hear it from you before January 15, not after. Example: A Five-Agent Medicare Agency's Close-Out Week This is an illustrative example, not a real client — a composite built to show the checklist in practice, not a measured outcome. A five-agent agency books its close-out work for the Monday after December 7. By Wednesday, the team has confirmed 94% of submitted enrollments as carrier-received; the other 6% turn out to be three clients whose applications stalled at the carrier and needed a follow-up call to resubmit before the window fully closed out administratively. The dedupe pass turns up eleven duplicate contact records created during the October call surge — all eleven get merged before they can confuse a renewal call in the spring. SOA filing is confirmed complete for every AEP appointment except two, both traced to a rep who'd been saving them locally instead of uploading them, caught and fixed the same week instead of surfacing during an audit. The agency tags 38 existing MA clients as "monitor for OEP" based on hesitation noted during their AEP call, and by the third week of January, four of them have called back wanting to revisit their plan — exactly the group the agency expected to hear from. FAQ When does the Annual Enrollment Period end, and when do changes take effect? AEP runs October 15 through December 7. Changes made during that window take effect January 1, provided the plan receives the request by December 7. Who can use the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period? Only people already enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan. It isn't open to someone newly eligible for Medicare or someone currently on Original Medicare who wants to switch into Medicare Advantage for the first time. How many changes can someone make during the Medicare Advantage OEP? One. They can switch to a different MA plan or drop MA entirely and return to Original Medicare, but only once during the January 1 through March 31 window. What's the real deadline for ACA Marketplace coverage? Open Enrollment runs through January 15. Enrolling by December 15 gets coverage starting January 1; enrolling between December 16 and January 15 pushes the start date to February 1. What should get checked first in the week after AEP closes? Whether…
Where AgencyView fits
Keep reading
Share: Facebook · LinkedIn · X · Email
All articles · AgencyView